Hiring Freeze Leadership Guide
What to Do When Hiring is Paused But Leadership Can't Be
Hiring may be stalled for your team right now, but leadership can’t be.
Whether you’re facing a headcount freeze, waiting on budget approvals, or just unsure what comes next, the challenge remains the same: How do you lead your team and plan ahead when you can’t hire the way you want to?
The Hiring Freeze in Numbers
As you navigate hiring pauses, delays, or freezing, here’s what’s happening across the market, according to recent employment data.
Change by Organization Size
29,000 Jobs
Small employers (1-19 employees)
18,000 Jobs
Small employers (20-49 employees)
12,000 Jobs
Midsize employers (50-249 employees)
27,000 Jobs
Midsize employers (250-499 employees)
30,000 Jobs
Large employers (500+ employees)
Change by Industry
5,000 Jobs
Information
52,000 Jobs
Education & health services
14,000 Jobs
Financial activities
56,000 Jobs
Professional & business services
32,000 Jobs
Leisure & hospitality
5,000 Jobs
Other services
The Hidden Costs of "Just Waiting" During Hiring Freezes
What Most Managers Don't Realize Leading Through A Hiring Freeze
When you put hiring on hold, you don’t just pause growth – you create ripple effects that impact team performance in ways many leaders don’t anticipate.
Companies are taking significantly longer to make hiring decisions, with 60% reporting increased time-to-hire. While organizations deliberate and wait for clarity, teams stretch to cover gaps and competitors who stayed strategic gain market advantages.
Reality Check: The money saved on salaries of delayed hiring decisions often gets offset by decreased productivity and increased turnover risk.
Team members naturally question company stability when growth plans are repeatedly delayed. High performers begin exploring other opportunities, and your most valuable people – exactly the ones competitors want to attract – start considering their options.
On top of that, merit increases averaged only 3.2% in 2025, while market rates for new hires climbed higher. This creates internal pay compression where your existing team feels undervalued while you can’t compete for new talent. Meanwhile, only 12% of organizations feel prepared for pay transparency requirements, setting up future retention problems.
Key Insight: When tenured employees earn less than what you'd pay a new hire for the same role, you've created a retention challenge that extends beyond the hiring freeze.
Perhaps the most significant cost is strategic drift. Leaders get stuck in reactive mode instead of strategic planning. Important projects get delayed while teams wait for “the right time” to grow. Innovation slows as people focus on maintaining current operations rather than advancing initiatives.
The outcome? Organizations that simply wait emerge from freezes behind competitors who used the pause strategically.
5-Step Action Plan for Leading Through a Hiring Freeze
If you’re seeing signs of strain but can’t grow your team just yet, don’t wait for headcount to open back up. Strong hiring freeze leadership means taking action now – with the team you have today.
Here’s a practical, lightweight toolkit to help team leads and managers stabilize, refocus, and stay ready for the next phase.
1. Run a Quick Capacity Check
When hiring is on hold, it’s easy to assume your team can “just stretch.” But is that really sustainable?
Use these benchmark utilization rates to assess how maxed-out your team might be:
| Role | Target Utilization Rate |
|---|---|
| Producers | 80% |
| Supervisors | 75% |
| Leaders | 63% |
| Owners | 25% |
Even a quick gut check works:
- What work feels unsustainable right now?
- Where are we missing key skills or coverage?
- What’s being dropped… quietly?
Related resource: Planning headcount using AGI + utilization rates – learn how to calculate needs before you post a role.
2. Re-Prioritize Using the “3-Bucket” Model
Don’t wait for things to slow down – make space now. Try this exercise with your team:
| Bucket | Definition | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Must-Do 🟢 | Critical, time-sensitive work | Client deadlines, revenue-driving projects |
| Nice-to-Do 🟡 | Important, but can wait | Internal initiatives, stretch goals |
| Pause-for-Now 🔴 | Low ROI or bandwidth-busting tasks | Legacy reports, “nice idea” projects |
Use this to clarify what matters during the freeze, not just after.
3. Host a “Freeze Reset” Team Meeting
The freeze is real, so talk about it. Bring your team together for a short, honest reset:
What’s not changing right now
What we can control together
What success looks like in this season
What support people need in the next 30–60 days
Tip: Ask each person to name one thing that would make their work easier this month.
4. Build Your “Future-Ready” File
Can’t hire now? That’s OK. Start building your hiring strategy for later.
- Outline your next 1–2 roles
- Create short lists of freelancers or consultants to call when the greenlight hits
- Document role gaps
- Keep a pulse on evolving skills and org structure needs
Need help with flexible hiring options? See how Celarity supports project-based talent.
5. Invest in Low-Lift Development
No budget for big learning programs? No problem. Here’s what “growth” can look like during a freeze:
- Peer mentoring or cross-functional shadowing
- A mini book club on leadership or creativity
- A shared learning doc with new tools, AI prompts, or frameworks
- Internal “stretch” projects with clear start/end dates
The goal? Show your team that growth hasn’t stopped, it just looks different right now.
Hiring freezes don’t have to freeze your leadership. While other are stuck waiting for “better times,” you have the data, strategies, and insights to move forward strategically.
The companies that emerge stronger aren’t the ones who just survived the freeze, they’re the ones who used it to build competitive advantages. Your team is watching how you lead through uncertainty. Your competitors are hoping you’ll stay stuck. And your future success depends on what you do right now, not what you’ll do when the freeze ends.
Expert Insights: A Conversation with Industry Leaders
We recently held a LinkedIn Live conversation with Debbie Schwake, fractional CMO and career transition community leader, Sarah Morgan, senior recruiter at Celarity, and Jamie Duong, Director of Marketing at Celarity, about navigating this challenging landscape.
Key takeaways from their discussion:
The interview marathon is real: One recent job seeker went through 22 rounds of interviews for a single director-level role. Yes, 22. While that’s extreme, lengthy hiring processes have become the norm rather than the exception. The silver lining? We’re seeing more people actually landing roles after these extended processes.
The “unicorn role” trap: Companies keep asking for candidates who can do three jobs perfectly. Here’s the problem: when you hire someone to cover marketing, design, and project management, you often get someone who’s mediocre at all three instead of excellent at one. Smart organizations are rethinking this approach and turning to specialists and fractional experts instead.
Contract work is the new normal: Entry-level positions are almost exclusively contract roles now. Mid-level roles are heading that direction too. Companies are saving their permanent positions for senior leadership roles where they need long-term strategic thinking and culture building.
Communication matters more than updates: Candidates don’t need constant good news – they need to know you haven’t forgotten about them. Even a “no news yet, but we’re still moving forward” message beats radio silence. People can handle uncertainty; they struggle with feeling invisible.
Watch the full conversation or read the breakdown to dig deeper!
Moving Forward with Confidence
Hiring freezes don’t have to mean leadership freezes. While you may not be able to add headcount immediately, you can use this time to strengthen your team, refine your processes, and position yourself for success when conditions improve.
The organizations that emerge strongest from this period will be those that viewed the pause as an opportunity to build rather than simply wait. Your team is looking to you for direction and confidence – this is your chance to demonstrate both.
Ready to turn your hiring freeze into a strategic advantage? Contact our team to discuss how we can help you build talent pipelines, optimize your current resources, and prepare for your next growth phase.
A Little About Celarity
Celarity is the most award-winning Staffing, Recruiting, and HR Consulting firm on a mission to Create Happy Careers. We’re proud to be a family-owned firm with Minnesota roots and a national reach.
Our NPS scores ranks among the top 5% of companies worldwide!
Best Places to Work
For seven years in a row, Celarity has been named a Best Places to Work
Glassdoor
Celarity is one of the only staffing recruiting & consultancy firms to win the prestigious Best Places to Work award
ClearlyRated Staffing Awards
For the sixth year in a row, Celarity earned top ratings from our clients with 100% satisfaction
